Penis or Balls?

[Woggler58 (imported)]

I don't think many read the initail question fully.

If the choice were between losing the penis or the whole package (balls and penis) ....

I read the initial question carefully and found it ambiguous, the meaning turning on what "full" meant in "full castration." The next several sentences in the question however seemed to have a context that the choice was either/or in nature: choice of either penectomy or bilateral orchiectomy. So I took "full" to mean the equivalent of "bilateral." BME has long regarded removal of the entire package of external genitals as "Nullification", perhaps to resolve confusion over what the term "castration" includes. So I replied accordingly, also heeding the question's clear applicability just to males who didn't want to lose anything but hypothetically would be forced to lose something.

[Obi Wan Kenobi (imported)]

I would go for the penis. I still like to be horny and the balls are good for staying in shape, but being totally smooth should be also looking nice

[Nidaho Rachel (imported)]

I'm like _g ,I would go for the M to F surgery and still live most of my life as male.When I retire I would like to transition to female full time. I wouldn't want to go through what castr8edmale did to become this way. I wish one could get this type of surgery in the US with out having to live female full time.

[weestub (imported)]

I'm not keen on the hassle of hormone replacement, so I'd opt to lose my penis and hope to be allowed to keep just enough to get a finger and thumb round for peeing. Considering my nick, I'm not sure just how forced this surgery would be though

[Mac (imported)]

I'm like _g ,I would go for the M to F surgery and still live most of my life as male.When I retire I would like to transition to female full time. I wouldn't want to go through what castr8edmale did to become this way. I wish one could get this type of surgery in the US with out having to live female full time.

It would be nice if that surgery was more readily available without having to live full-time and getting psychological approval.

[Summit22 (imported)]

I'd have to loose my balls, even though my cock is mostly useless now. It's always been a desire and I hope one day to be in that special eunuch club!

[gjvr2001 (imported)]

I would choose to lose balls as HRT can sort of replace them.

[jockey_elance (imported)]

I love questions like this, it should be on a national survey or something. Anyway i choose...

BALLS!!!

[emasculation (imported)]

If I had to choose between just getting a penectomy or total emasculation. I would definitely have my whole package removed. I have wanted my balls gone for a long time and have considered getting my penis removed, so that would definitely be what I want

[sydneyguy26 (imported)]

Take the penis away please!

[Twinsenboy (imported)]

I think I maybe have to cut off and sell one of my testicles to be able to pay for a circumcision, which is very expensive where I live..

[Uncle Flo (imported)]

I think I maybe have to cut off and sell one of my testicles to be able to pay for a circumcision, which is very expensive where I live..

Perhaps, the cost of a circumcision is directly related to the size of a penis so you should feel complimented. --FLO--

[Stumpycoon (imported)]

I'd want to lose the balls first. The idea of having a princes wand in my dick, and no balls, is oddly tempting.

[Twinsenboy (imported)]

I'd want to lose the balls first. The idea of having a princes wand in my dick, and no balls, is oddly tempting.

Yeah, well ever since I saw that infamous, old penectomy video I've kinda feared loosing my cock to a fat, crazy doctor!

The castration stories makes me horny.. and scared too, at the same time. I bet reality is a different matter.

[moi621 (imported)]

I'd want to lose the balls first. The idea of having a princes wand in my dick, and no balls, is oddly tempting.

( )0( ) think of the exquisite frustration of having a full functioning sac and no joy stick.

Try as you might to accept "it" on the prostate or perineum or scrotum & balls,

just an ooze at best, no pumpity pump action. Something always missing in the best experience.

You Can't Go Home Again

The balls? Hell. There is always HRT even by dermal application. No finality. You can freeze some for kids later.

I have had Penectomy fantasies since the lady of my dreams left me.

Previously, I might imagine a woman taking my balls.

This time she took my dick. Often, when I would do "it" - very, very past tense

I imagined I was left with a strap on rod to satisfy a new lady.

Moi

[Dave (imported)]

Yeah, well ever since I saw that infamous, old penectomy video I've kinda feared loosing my cock to a fat, crazy doctor!

The castration stories makes me horny.. and scared too, at the same time. I bet reality is a different matter.

reality will be surgical drapes, stirrups (most likely), and white-clad dumpy people in a sterile, cold room.

Nothing sexy.

I used to get intravenal pylograms (kidney checkups) on a regular basis and there wasn't anything or anyone sexy involved.

[kitchkinet18 (imported)]

I plan to keep my penis forever. My nuts and my scrotum can go. I dislike nullification and penectomy. Eunuch or bust!

[minuteman (imported)]

If I had to choose between penectomy and "full castration", I'd chose the latter. If I lost my penis I don't hink I could handle the frustration, so the balls (and scrotum) would have to go as well.

If the choice was either/or, I'd go for the castration (+scrotum - no floppy bag thanks), with circumcision as a side order.

Oh - and laser hair removal. If I'm gonna look silly I might as well do it properly

[luke1812 (imported)]

Keep the cock, loose the balls.

[erikboy (imported)]

Penis is pretty useful as a urine stream directing device.

[inthefuture (imported)]

My penis, as I'm sure that I can still find ways of achieving orgasm without it. (would like the smoother crotch without any bulge when I get turned on by an attractive female) But I don't want to lose my balls and loose my sexual desire nor do I want to have to go the "T" replacement route.

I much prefder to lose my penis... It 's small, and, I have a constant strong desire to masturbate; I find masturbating a chore, one that is not offset by the supposed "pleasure" of the resulting orgasm. Sitting to void is not something that would concern me, I nearly alwalys do so now anyway. I would rather have the urethra exit from its original location behind the scrotum... fecal contaminTion...

I want to keep my testes so that I remain a physical male and not depend on HRT.

I would like more men to stop masturbating, if not voluntarily, then by assistance (!) Those are the type of stories I enjoy most (including de-cocked slaves that are left with their testes) because I want mine simplly gone.

Any "takers?"

ITF (As in de-cocked 'In The Future')

[Barrister (imported)]

This is directed more towards those that are just curious about castration/penectomy (or solely fantasize!) but I was curious, if you were forced to choose between a penectomy or full castration, which would you choose and why? I direct this towards those that are only curious, as those of us who find a sexual thrill in or are truly seeking castration/penectomy would have differing reasons for choosing the way we would. So, if a guy who didn't really want to lose any parts was forced to choose, I have to wonder which would he rather live without. Thanks for indulging me!

In surgery for a staph infection that had spread through my lower abdomen through thighs my penis was severely mutilated and I was left with not much of a penis with very little nervous feeling. Afterwards the doctor took pride in telling me that he originally felt my testicles would have needed to be removed but he saved them.

It has been a life of Hell with full passions and drive with no way to really relieve myself or enjoy a full relationship (I am hetero) with a woman. Had I a choice I would never choose a penectomy withou being castrated as well.

[Mac (imported)]

Penis is pretty useful as a urine stream directing device.

If you have penectomy with a proper reroute there will not be any need to worry about proper directing of the urine stream.