True - Michael Jackson has kicked the bucket....NaturalEunuch wrote: Sat Apr 05, 2025 12:24 pmI'm sure we're not. That kind of singing is out of date anyway.dandelion wrote: Sat Apr 05, 2025 10:45 amWhile we don’t have kids with fully developed adult lungs, we do have better acoustics in modern theaters, and like Wheely said, far superior sound recording and sound engineering technologies. I don’t think we are missing that much.NaturalEunuch wrote: Sat Apr 05, 2025 5:22 am The advantage a castrato has over the kid in the recording is the castrato can hit those high tones as an adult with fully developed adult lungs.


Classic Opera and so forth may be out of style, but think about how many rock / country / etc. singers (some female) sing in high ranges or falsetto... (Back before I learned that adult castration doesn't cause voice changes, I know I used to joke about how many black artists sounded like they had a pair of vice-grips applied to certain bits...) How many high pitched kids place really well in "America's Got Stars" and similar reality talent shows?
I would not make any bets that a modern castrati voice could not become a super-star today assuming that his other performing skills were also 'star quality" (I'm not asking anyone to volunteer their kid for the test...)
WheelyFixed