You can now share longer posts, personal updates, and community reflections in our new Blog section.
Visit the Blogs page to explore or start your own.

Let your voice be heard

Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

For castration-related posts that just don’t seem to fit anywhere else.
User avatar
WheelyFixed
Lead Moderator
Articles: 1
Posts: 459
Joined: Sun Dec 01, 2024 8:58 am
Location: Metro-Boston, MA, USA
Has thanked: 47 times
Been thanked: 159 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by WheelyFixed »

Bibiballs wrote: Tue Jan 21, 2025 7:36 am Thanks NaturalEunuch for the experience you share.

I didn't know that it could also affect memory.
I know some guys had frail bones.
Do you have a suitable diet to compensate for the lack of hormones ?

About erections, can we hope to cure the problem with injections ?
Or do we have to admit that the end of sex, desire and feelings ? :(
The effect on memory is sometimes reported, others say no problem for most, it is supposedly fairly uncommon and minor (especially if

Osteoporosis is a definite and real problem, at the very least you should plan on getting a bone density scan before or very shortly after castration to get a baseline, and repeat as often as your insurance will allow (typically every 2-3 years) to catch any problems before they start. Calcium and D3 supplements are highly recommended (preferably Calcium citrate as that is the most readily absorbed form) Most docs will also want you to use some form of hormone replacement, and doing so avoids or minimizes many of the bad effects, especially the bone loss and mental health aspects. Interestingly T and E are essentially identical for this, except that T MAY help maintain erections (but some will ask what's the point of getting rid of the natural T factories in order to replace w/ artificial, except that it does give some control over the level)

Exercise and calcium will help minimize bone loss if going hormone free, but they won't stop it... Otherwise there are no major diet considerations beyond generally watching quantities to reduce the tendency for weight gain. (Many also find low-carb diets are helpful in this regard, I do.)

Erections are unpredictable - some can get them with just extra effort, others find injections or pills help enough, some find a short term boost in T does it. and others find NOTHING helps....

As I said, when deciding if you want to be castrated you should ASSUME that you WILL be 100% IMPOTENT and if the idea of that is not acceptable, then you should NOT get fixed. Given how much concern you have been expressing, I would really urge you to think very long and hard (pun intended) about the idea.... Is the idea of NEVER having another erection acceptable?

There is NOTHING that can guarantee the ability to get it up after surgery.... That said, it is still possible to have sex in other ways that don't involve penetrating (i.e. being "bottom" if gay) or use 'tools' if your partner wants them. Desire and feelings are still there, they just aren't likely to be as overwhelming, and probably will be different.

WheelyFixed
Paraplegic - T-5, ASIA-B. 2010 Injury left non-functional & frustrated. 4/24/22, stop T. 5/4 start 3.75mg Lupron. 6/29 - T ~0. 7/7 - start E. 9/2 stop Lupron. 3/30/23 - GOT LETTERS! surgery (O&S) 9/28/23. Doing 0.1mg/day E patch as HRT
Bibiballs
Articles: 0
Posts: 21
Joined: Thu Jan 16, 2025 12:15 am
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 16 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by Bibiballs »

Thanks to WheelyFixed for the advice.

The worse I fear is not the lack of full erection but the loos of desire and feelings.

About Cat Bohannon who claims castrated men live longer. Does anyone know if she has a science degree?

I'm maybe wrong but what I've read sounds like a feminist point of view.
User avatar
NaturalEunuch
Articles: 0
Posts: 206
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2024 6:23 am
Location: USA
Has thanked: 136 times
Been thanked: 116 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by NaturalEunuch »

Here is Cat Bohannon's bio from her book publisher:

CAT BOHANNON is a researcher and author with a Ph.D. from Columbia University in the evolution of narrative and cognition. Her essays and poems have appeared in Scientific American, Mind, Science Magazine, The Best American Nonrequired Reading, The Georgia Review, The Story Collider, and Poets Against the War. She lives with her family in Seattle.

Bohannon's comments about "two little death nuggets" are colorful and draw attention, but I doubt she's done much direct research on the topic.

I'm sure she's referencing several studies that indicate that eunuchs live 10-14 years longer than fully-equipped men. The conclusion is that testosterone plays a role in shortening men's lives. However, the age that a eunuch is castrated makes a difference. If you get castrated at an advanced age, you likely won't get full longevity benefits.
"In many ways, a eunuch is not a damaged human, but an improved one."
Bibiballs
Articles: 0
Posts: 21
Joined: Thu Jan 16, 2025 12:15 am
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 16 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by Bibiballs »

It's certainly a difficult decision. Would I be happier, healthier, longer-lived without testicles ?

As I wrote it previously, what I fear the most is not the lack of full erection but the loos of desire and feelings.
The loos of libido is more important than the loos of my balls.

For several months I started to have erectile disfunction and I discovered the feeling of having a limp cock.

A semi-hard dangling penis makes the strange sensation of desire and frustration mixed together that I never known before.

What would be if castrated is what I wonder...
User avatar
NaturalEunuch
Articles: 0
Posts: 206
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2024 6:23 am
Location: USA
Has thanked: 136 times
Been thanked: 116 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by NaturalEunuch »

It's a fact that your libido will be reduced if you are castrated. Many eunuchs are happy to have their sex drive gone completely.

If you want to move forward, consider trying some form of chemical castration and experience how it feels. This is reversible if you don't like it. On the other hand, surgery is permanent and there's no going back.

You need to weigh all the positives and negatives to decide what is best for you.
"In many ways, a eunuch is not a damaged human, but an improved one."
User avatar
mounds_dont
Articles: 0
Posts: 46
Joined: Sat Dec 28, 2024 7:38 am
Location: Seattle
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 30 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by mounds_dont »

A word of caution on the "reversible". One of the side effects of T blocking medications is permanent ED. No matter what you do, ask lots of questions, get lots of opinions, and make an informed decision. I tend to look at what can go wrong, will. So when I am making decisions, I always ask "Can I live with the down side?" Many people only look at the up side and never consider the down side. I am just saying as our resident pessimist, the down side is there.
User avatar
NaturalEunuch
Articles: 0
Posts: 206
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2024 6:23 am
Location: USA
Has thanked: 136 times
Been thanked: 116 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by NaturalEunuch »

mounds_dont wrote: Wed Jan 22, 2025 9:35 am A word of caution on the "reversible". One of the side effects of T blocking medications is permanent ED. No matter what you do, ask lots of questions, get lots of opinions, and make an informed decision. I tend to look at what can go wrong, will. So when I am making decisions, I always ask "Can I live with the down side?" Many people only look at the up side and never consider the down side. I am just saying as our resident pessimist, the down side is there.
That's good advice. I think I read the longer you take the castration drugs, the more likely it is you will have ED problems when you stop.
"In many ways, a eunuch is not a damaged human, but an improved one."
User avatar
WheelyFixed
Lead Moderator
Articles: 1
Posts: 459
Joined: Sun Dec 01, 2024 8:58 am
Location: Metro-Boston, MA, USA
Has thanked: 47 times
Been thanked: 159 times

Posting Rank

Re: Is castration after 50 avoid prostate problems ?

Post by WheelyFixed »

From reports and discussion on EAv2, SHORT (1-3 months) worth of chemical castration with the usual drugs for it is USUALLY reversible, though it can take a fairly long time to get back to 'normal'.

Some have reported penis shrinkage during the CC period (The erectile tissue needs to be 'exercised' regularly by getting erections or it loses some of it's elasticity) and this may or may not come back.

It is worth noting that a "trial run" of Chemical Castration before surgery is strongly recommended in the SOCv8, so it's not a bad idea.

WheelyFixed
Paraplegic - T-5, ASIA-B. 2010 Injury left non-functional & frustrated. 4/24/22, stop T. 5/4 start 3.75mg Lupron. 6/29 - T ~0. 7/7 - start E. 9/2 stop Lupron. 3/30/23 - GOT LETTERS! surgery (O&S) 9/28/23. Doing 0.1mg/day E patch as HRT
Post Reply